In a 600-ft.-long saltwater wave tank on the coast of New Jersey, a team of New Jersey Institute of Technology (NJIT) researchers is conducting the largest-ever simulation of the Deepwater Horizon spill to determine more precisely where hundreds of thousands of gallons of oil dispersed following the drilling rig’s explosion in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010.
Led by Michel Boufadel, director of NJIT’s Center for Natural Resources (CNR), the initial phase of the experiment involved releasing several thousand gallons of oil from a one-inch pipe dragged along the bottom of the tank in order to reproduce ocean current conditions. “The facility at Ohmsett allows us to simulate as closely as possible the conditions at sea, and to thus observe how droplets of oil formed and the direction and distance they traveled,” Boufadel said.
Later this summer, his team will conduct the second phase of the experiment, when they will apply dispersants to the oil as it shoots into the tank to observe the effects on droplet formation and trajectory.
His team’s research, conducted at the U.S. Department of the Interior’s Ohmsett facility at Naval Weapons Station Earle in Leonardo, N.J., was detailed in a recent article, “The perplexing physics of oil dispersants,” in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS).
“These experiments are the largest ever conducted by a university in terms of the volume of oil released and the scale,” he noted. “The data we obtained, which has not been published yet, is being used by other researchers to calibrate their models.”
The team expects to come away from these experiments with insights they can apply to a variety of ocean-based oil releases.
"Rather than limiting ourselves to a forensic investigation of the Deepwater Horizon release, we are using that spill to explore spill scenarios more generally," Boufadel said. “Our goal is not to prepare for the previous spill, but to broaden the horizons to explore various scenarios."
More than nine years after the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig exploded, sending up to 900,000 tons of oil and natural gas into the Gulf of Mexico, there are, however, lingering questions about the safety and effectiveness of a key element of the emergency response: injecting chemicals a mile below the ocean surface to break up oil spewing from the ruptured sub-sea wellhead to prevent it from reaching environmentally sensitive regions.
To date, spill cleanups have focused primarily on removing or dispersing oil on the ocean surface and shoreline, habitats deemed more important ecologically. Knowledge of the deep ocean is in general far murkier, and at the time of the accident, BP’s drilling operation was the deepest in the world.
Two years ago, Boufadel and collaborators from the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, NJIT, Texas A&M University and the Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology pooled their scientific and technical expertise to provide some of the first answers to these controversial policy questions.
The team began by developing physical models and computer simulations to determine the course the oil and gas took following the eruption, including the fraction of larger, more buoyant droplets that floated to the surface and the amount of smaller droplets entrapped deep below it due to sea stratification and currents. Boufadel and Lin Zhao, a postdoctoral researcher in the CNR, developed a model that predicted the size of droplets and gas bubbles emanating from the wellhead during the sub-surface blowout; they then factored in water pressure, temperature and oil properties into the model, and employed it to analyze the effects of the injected dispersants on this stream.
"Among other tests of our model, we studied the hydrodynamics of various plumes of oil jetting into different wave tanks," Zhao noted. Researchers at Texas A&M in turn created a model to study the movement of pollutants away from the wellhead.
The researchers determined that the use of dispersants had a substantial impact on air quality in the region of the spill by reducing the amount of toxic compounds such as benzene that reached the surface of the ocean, thus protecting emergency workers on the scene from the full brunt of the pollution. Their study was published in PNAS.
“Government and industry responders were faced with an oil spill of unprecedented size and sea depth, pitting them in a high-stakes battle against big unknowns,” Christopher Reddy, a senior scientist at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, and Samuel Arey, a senior researcher at the Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, wrote in Oceanus magazine.
“Environmental risks posed by deep-sea petroleum releases are difficult to predict and assess due to the lack of prior investigations,” Boufadel noted. “There is also a larger debate about the impact of chemical dispersants. There is a school of thought that says all of the oil should be removed mechanically.”
Boufadel added that the water-soluble and volatile compounds that did not reach the surface were entrapped in a water mass that formed a stable intrusion at 900 to 1,300 meters below the surface.
“These predictions depend on local weather conditions that can vary from day to day. However, we predict that clean-up delays would have been much more frequent if subsurface dispersant injection had not been applied,” Reddy and Arey said, adding, “But this is not the final say on the usage of dispersants.”
The current experiment is an attempt to provide more definitive answers.
New NOAA Report Examines National Oil Po
Active Cleanup from Deepwater Horizon Ac
Live Feed from the E/V Nautilus: ECOGIG
Teledyne Oil & Gas Announces the Release
New Exploration Opportunity - Offshore M
Deepwater Mining in Norway
OceanGate Inc. Dives on Oil Platform for
Study Describes How an Oil Slick Could I
Gas and Oil Discoveries in the Askja Pro
Professor and Graduate Students From Nov
Tracking the Last Mile Before Oil Meets
OIL & GAS UK Discuss New Offshore Well I
New £8 Million Training Center for the O
Deepwater Horizon: Identifying Harmful E
100% Data Return as Metocean Services Co
A Quantum Change in Offshore Oil and Gas
When Whales and Oil Rigs Meet
New Tool Available to Help Track Spilled
Starts Up Na Kika Phase 3 in Deepwater G
Scientists Train the Next Generation on
DeepWater Buoyancy Delivers Flotation Te
Florida State University: Researchers Fi
Tankers Stack Up in Port of Houston in W
New Study Shows Heart Abnormalities in F
Pellerin Energy Group Sets Record In Dee
March: Deepwater Power Point provides a
Gas and Oil Discovery in the Valemon Are
Total Discovers Oil in Deep Offshore Ivo
BP: Active Shoreline Cleanup Operations
CSA GeoPortal Aids Rapid Oil Spill Respo
CSA Conducts Benthic Habitat Surveys for
Applus RTD Unveils Pioneering Deepwater
UGA Research Examines Fate of Methane Fo
Study Evaluates Synthetic Aperture Radar
Sonar Could Spot Oil Spills Hidden by Ar
Joint Finnish-Swedish Surveillance Opera
Secretary Jewell Announces Award of Firs
CSB Releases New Computer Animation of 2
CSA Conducts Substantial Sediment Profil
The CLOV Deepwater Development Comes on
Perfect Score on Deepwater Tests for TMT
DeepWater Buoyancy Chosen for Ocean Obse
Statoil Opens New Research Center – a Mi
CAMAC Energy Discovers Multiple Oil and
BW Offshore has signed contract with Pre
Study at Deepwater Horizon Spill Site Fi
ABS to Class Second-generation Ultra Dee
Shell announces first oil from Cardamom
Teledyne Oil & Gas Announces Record Cont
BMT Appoints New Sales Manager for Offsh
MTN Builds Houston Team to Expand on 20
Highly Distributed Oil & Gas Workforces
Kongsberg Maritime Launches K-SIM Naviga
Guildford and Aberdeen Based Kongsberg O
DNV GL Win Multi Service Contract from M
Unique System FZE in association with HY
Ennsub delivers DEEP 4000 deepwater depl
February - Feature Story - Teledyne Oil
Horizon 2020 Programme to Develop Revolu
Deepwater Data & Maps Now Available
Horizon 2020 programme to Develop Revolu
LATC Marine Brings Next Generation Damen
Deepwater Horizon Trustees Announce Agre
Brazilian Offshore Oil Field Takes Nexan
Neptune Awarded 5-Year Offshore Diving C
NOAA Announces New Deepwater Horizon Oil
Emerging Markets Communications Showcase
Bob The Drifter Inspires Singapore Class
Elastec Launches New Offshore Oil Spill
Chukar Waterjet Unveils Deepwater Subsea
Deepwater Horizon Settled – Now What?
BOEM to Offer Almost 22 Million Acres in
3D at Depth Transforms Upstream Oil and
Schlumberger Launches Industry-First Mul
Egersund Group Sets New Record in Oil Sp
SUT to Host Deepwater Sessions at Offsho
ALSEAMAR Successfully Completed First Ge
Metocean Services Selects DeepWater Buoy
Subsea 7 Awarded Contract Offshore UK by
GZA GeoEnvironmental, Inc. Conducts Geot
Bibby Offshore Provides Lifeline to Oil
Harris CapRock Communications Provides O
NOAA, Deepwater Horizon Trustees Announc
Oil and Gas CEOs Jointly Declare Action
Horizon Geosciences Now the Largest User
Oil and Wind Have Joined Forces in DNV G
Modeling Study Quantifies Gas Bubbles Ef
Falcon Best for Perenco Oil in West Afri
DNV GL Conducts Largest Ever Controlled
Shedding Light on Oil Behaviors Before t
New Study Shows that Nitrogen Enhances M
ABB commissions cable link to deliver cl
One Horizon Group Signs VoIP-Supply Cont
SeaRobotics will Manufacture Lockheed Ma
Michigan State Police Upgrades Deepwater
Maersk Oil Awards Peterson Five-Year Int
DeepWater Buoyancy Produces New “Square”
Microbes Thrive Above Natural Oil Seeps
CSA Ocean Sciences Receives NOPP Deepwat