Responding to Russian challenges in NATO protected waters requires a deep understanding of the Northern European maritime environment, says a new report from the Center for Strategic & International Studies (CSIS). Challenges like detecting advanced submarines and gaining a holistic understanding of the maritime environment require that NATO and its partners advance their Maritime Domain Awareness (MDA) capabilities. The report’s authors make specific recommendations for creating MDA networks to enhance security in Northern Europe. The following is a summary of the Contested Seas report, which can be downloaded here.
Northern Europe, and specifically the Baltic and Norwegian Seas, has been the site of increasingly provocative and destabilizing Russian actions. The country’s use of a range of military, diplomatic, and economic tools to undermine the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) and its allies highlights the need to monitor and understand Russian activity. The region is characterized by complex factors like unique geographic features, considerable civilian maritime traffic, the presence of advanced Russian and Western military capabilities, and strategic proximity to Russia and the Kola peninsula, home to the Russian Northern Fleet. While the Norwegian and Baltic Seas do differ in key ways, they are linked by the emerging risk posed by Russia’s long-range strike capabilities.
Responding to Russian challenges across the competitive space requires a deep understanding of the Northern European maritime environment. Maritime Domain Awareness (MDA), defined by the United States as the effective understanding of anything associated with the maritime domain that could impact the security, safety, economy, or environment of a nation or region, is an exceptionally broad concept. At its core, MDA has three functions: the collection of raw data, the analysis of that data, and the action of disseminating information to and coordinating among the different components of the framework. In order to provide security in Northern Europe, NATO and its allies must use MDA frameworks to understand and respond to the challenges above, on, and underneath the sea, as well as the surrounding land environment.
While some constructive work has been done to address the evolving Russian threat, NATO and its partners must make changes to their current MDA capabilities to evolve alongside with it. Russia presents three challenges of particular concern to the MDA efforts in Northern Europe: maritime hybrid warfare, electronic and cyber warfare capabilities, and long-range strike systems.
The modern history of MDA begins in the United States, with Homeland Security Presidential Directive – 13 (HSPD-13) / National Security Presidential Directive – 41 (NSPD-41) issued in 2004 by President George W. Bush. The document lays out core interests for the United States to enhance security in the maritime domain and creates a cooperative framework to support MDA operations across different spheres. At the same time, the European concept of maritime security awareness was built upon the U.S. definition of the challenge, placed within the context of rising illicit traffic in the Mediterranean.
A weakness of the original MDA and Maritime Situational Awareness (MSA) concepts is that many of the associated capabilities and frameworks are focused on civil maritime issues. Given the global proliferation of advanced military capabilities, like antiship cruise missiles, NATO and its partners require a holistic understanding of the maritime environment that focuses on everything from civil maritime actions to high-end military operations and even issues associated with the maritime environment.
A key implication of the heightened maritime threat environment is the need to improve the integration of and attention to undersea aspects of MDA. Antisubmarine warfare (ASW), a traditional strength of Western naval intelligence and operations, has atrophied since the end of the Cold War. Today, Russian submarines with conventional long-range missiles pose a threat to NATO. ASW must be integrated with MDA to address these concerns. Comprehensive understanding of the undersea realm should extend beyond ASW. Russia’s amphibious special forces and combat swimmers threaten more than just military targets, including civilian vessels and undersea cables, which are an integral part of MDA. ASW technology can be useful in countering these and other threats.
In the Norwegian Sea, the biggest challenge for NATO is detecting advanced ultra-quiet submarines. This issue is sharpened by dramatically depleted stockpiles of sonobuoys, a constant need for increasingly advanced sonobuoy technology, and an American unwillingness to share highly classified information about the undersea domain. NATO would benefit from an apparatus like the ASW Operations Centers (ASWOC), used most prominently during the Cold War to streamline ASW operations. Integration of platforms is a challenge in the Baltic Sea as well, largely because Sweden and Finland are not NATO states, making data sharing challenging.
Frameworks like Sea Surveillance Co-Operation Baltic Sea (SUCBAS) and the Maritime Surveillance (MARSUR) project facilitate the work of regional states to address these issues but more must be done. Additionally, NATO monitoring of the Baltic region is largely domain specific and suffers from not examining the maritime domain holistically. The alliance and its partners should also act to focus on resiliency to continue to operate in the face of jamming and nonkinetic attacks from Russia.
The key to enhancing MDA capabilities in Northern Europe is the integration of frameworks across the maritime domain. Cooperation between NATO states and allies is vital to understanding the complex environment. The CSIS study team has identified seven recommendations of particular importance:
These priority recommendations are presented in detail in the report, along with others. Collectively, their implication would markedly enhance security in Northern Europe by closing identified gaps and ensuring capabilities for collection, analysis, and action in MDA.
By Kathleen H. Hicks, Senior Vice President; Henry A. Kissinger Chair; Director, International Security Program, CSIS and Andrew Metrick, Associate Fellow, International Security Program, CSIS
Bluefin Acquires SeeByte Adding New Soft
Speedcast Expands Its Global Maritime VS
Kongsberg Maritime Delivers First Set of
Digital Hydrography on Maritime Web Proc
Unique Maritime Group Locks In Key Appoi
Northern and Southern Hemisphere Clim
BioSonics Names CADDEN Authorized Servic
Nortek to Host the 2014 Northern Europea
Ultra Electronics USSI And Liquid Roboti
WOC FOSTERS INDUSTRY-GOVERNMENT COOPERAT
Ocean Industries Engage In EU Maritime P
Navies Now Looking to Address Skills Dec
Kongsberg Maritime Upgrades Market Leadi
Water-Level & Met Ocean Data Enable Safe
Kongsberg Maritime Provides Major Simula
Trenam Kemker Launches New Maritime Law
Kongsberg Mesotech Launches the M3 MARSE
Request for Information on Networked Mar
SAT-3/WASC/SAFE Consortium and Alcatel-L
Kongsberg Maritime Launches New Compact,
Kongsberg Maritime to Provide Turnkey Of
Emerging Markets Communications to Exhib
Kongsberg Maritime to Deliver Integrated
Kongsberg Maritime Integrated Vessel Con
GVF Announces Launch of 'Glossary' of Ma
Boeing and Liquid Robotics Sign Multi-Ye
AXYS Deploys First WindSentinel in Europ
Kongsberg Maritime Launches Innovative N
Unique Maritime Group Board Introduces N
Students Utilize WAM-V® Platform to Face
BMT and MSubs Collaborate to Deliver a M
Marlink Extends Maritime IT Service Offe
NW Marine Technology Summit Bolsters Mar
New Compact High Resolution Monochrome C
VELODYNE 3D LiDAR SENSOR ENABLES M.I.T./
Australian Army purchases VSTEP maritime
Kongsberg Maritime Launches K-SIM Naviga
Leidos Completes At-Sea Testing of Proto
ARRIS SecureMedia® Protects the Maritime
Kongsberg Maritime Launches New Bathymet
Inmarsat Maritime Strengthens Distributi
Maritime ICT Cloud Enables Ships to Join
Aalesund University College Upgrades to
Unique Maritime Group sets new standards
Inmarsat Announces Enhanced Maritime Pro
Unique Maritime Group Announces Rodney M
Kongsberg Maritime Launches New Improved
VSTEP Class A Simulator for Ho Chi Minh
ASV Wins Maritime Autonomy R&D Funding
KVH Expands mini-VSAT Broadband Network
Kongsberg Maritime Acquires Contros Syst
MCP and TMR Integrate to Seize Maritime
KVH Launches Global Conference Series to
James Fisher Completes Acquisition of Mo
NMRA Offers Maritime Student Scholarship
McMurdo and International Maritime Rescu
Emerging Markets Communications Showcase
Sonardyne Partners with NDI for Maritime
DNV GL Appoints Tor Svensen as Group EVP
Impartial Maritime VSAT Knowledge Resour
New Dynamic Positioning Course at Kongsb
Harris Corporation and exactEarth Team t
CMRE Successfully Demonstrates Systems f
SUT to Host Deepwater Sessions at Offsho
CONTROP Makes Waves with the iSea Family
Radio Hollands extends VSAT Coverage abo
International Maritime Security Associat
Saab Signs Maritime Mine Countermeasures
Seamlessly Integrate Ships into the Corp
OceanWise Develops Maritime Toolbar (MTB
New Award Recognizes Outstanding Efforts
MSI to Deliver 3 AXYS Technologies Buoys
Panasonic Avionics and Kymeta Bring Revo
Optimized Arctic Observations for Improv
TSG Delivers Unique, Real-Time Maritime
Oceaneering® Launches PortVision 360™ at
Maritime Mine Threat Experts Visit Saab
Australia: Plans for a State-of-the-Art
ORBIT Receives a Follow on Order for Its
Unique Group Expands Life Support Divisi
Industry Code of Conduct for Maritime Au
Kongsberg Maritime Ltd to Grow Rental Se
Kongsberg Maritime and Statoil Collabora
AUV Mullaya Arrives at Australian Mariti
Thuraya and IEC Telecom Join Forces to S
WOC and Dubai Maritime Cluster Agrees on
Gulf Stream Slowdown to Spare Europe fro
Black Sea Maritime Archaeological Projec
The Maritime Alliance Hosts San Diego Bl
Kongsberg Maritime and Symphotic Tii Sig
Arctic Domain Awareness Center Opens at
Surveyor Interceptor Hits New Record in
Sonardyne Strengthens Maritime Security
IHC IQIP’s Integrated Monopile Installer
RIMS BV Launch ‘Drone’ Inspection Servic
Wales Becomes Lead Partners of Ocean Ene
Sonardyne Appoints MARSS Group as Mariti
U.S. Maritime Technology Export Initiati
Electric Robotic Systems will Perform al
Ocean News & Technology is a publication of TSC
7897 SW Jack James Drive
Suite A, Stuart, FL 34997
(772)-221-7720